Jazz Chisholm -- Prospect Evaluation

Jazz Chisholm Jr. is a 5'11", 184-pound left-handed batter who debuted professionally on September 1, 2020. The Nassau, Bahamas native has played multiple infield positions (shortstop, second base, third base) throughout his career. Over 118 at-bats this season, he maintains a .212 batting average with a .299 on-base percentage, .331 slugging percentage, and 3 home runs. Chisholm was ranked highly as a prospect across multiple organizations: he was the Arizona Diamondbacks' #1 prospect in 2019 before being traded to the Miami Marlins, where he ranked #4 in 2021. Baseball America ranked him as a top-100 prospect multiple times, peaking at #59 in 2019. He was recognized for his power hitting and defensive infield arm strength. In 2023, Chisholm was traded from Miami to the New York Yankees. His recent career has been impacted by injuries, including a left oblique strain (2024) and right oblique strain (2025), resulting in multiple stints on the 10-day injured list and rehab assignments with Yankees affiliates.

Jasrado Chisholm, a 19-year-old shortstop prospect signed from the Bahamas two years ago, is considered by scouts to be the Arizona Diamondbacks' best prospect. The player, who goes by 'Jazz,' possesses smooth fielding actions, a big swing, and notable confidence in his abilities. Chisholm is known for his energetic play on the field and aggressive approach at the plate.

Chisholm has expressed ambitious long-term goals, stating he wants to be a great major league player capable of competing for 15-20 years. For the current season, he has set a specific target of batting .400. When discussing his playing style, Chisholm references the swings of Robinson Cano and Ken Griffey Jr., and models his leadership approach after Derek Jeter.

His professional experience remains limited to a half-season in 2016 with Missoula of the rookie-level Pioneer League, where he accumulated 249 at-bats. In that debut season, he produced a .281 batting average with 21 extra-base hits, including 9 home runs. During spring training, Chisholm was among the Diamondbacks' leaders in home runs during minor league camp, demonstrating continued development at age 19.

Jazz Chisolm, acquired by the Miami Marlins at the 2019 trade deadline, is an elite athlete shortstop prospect with a Future Value grade of 55. His defensive skills, speed, arm strength, and power are all above-average to excellent (55-60 grade range), representing a rare combination for the position where defense typically dominates value. When making contact, Chisolm generates exceptional power with 40% of his career hits going for extra bases and recorded exit velocities reaching 112 mph, comparable to elite sluggers.

However, Chisolm's most significant weakness is his contact ability, graded at just 35/45. His approach is characterized by an overly aggressive, pull-heavy swing that relies on sheer strength and athleticism rather than pitch recognition. This has resulted in a career minor league batting average of .255 with a 30% strikeout rate and 10% walk rate. Pitchers have successfully exploited his free-swinging tendencies by pitching away from his power. While his batted ball profile (45% fly balls, 25% line drives) mirrors All-Star Alex Bregman's approach, Chisolm's inability to consistently make contact prevents him from achieving similar results. Overall, his elite physical tools are significantly limited by his lack of batting discipline and contact skills.

Jazz Chisholm Jr. is a 26-year-old infielder from Nassau, Bahamas, who made his MLB debut on September 1, 2020. Standing 5'11" and weighing 184 lbs, he bats left-handed and throws right. His current statistics reflect limited performance with 11 at-bats, a .182 batting average, .250 on-base percentage, and .182 slugging percentage with no home runs.

Chisholm has an extensive prospect ranking history across multiple organizations. He was ranked as the Arizona Diamondbacks' #1 prospect in 2019 and later the Miami Marlins' #4 prospect in 2021. Baseball America ranked him #59 overall prospect in 2019 and #77 in 2021. He received recognition as the Best Power Hitter in the Miami Marlins organization in 2020 and was noted for his Best Infield Arm while with Arizona in 2018. His minor league achievements include rankings in the Southern League (#7 in 2019), California League (#6 in 2018), and Arizona Fall League (#4 in 2018).

Chisholm was traded to the New York Yankees from the Miami Marlins in exchange for catcher Agustin Ramirez, second baseman Jared Serna, and shortstop Abrahan Ramirez. His recent career transactions reveal multiple injury-related placements on the 10-day injured list, including a right oblique strain (April 2025) and left elbow sprain (August 2024), with subsequent rehabilitation assignments and activations documenting his recovery progression with the Yankees organization.

The Miami Marlins traded starting pitcher Zac Gallen to the Arizona Diamondbacks to acquire 21-year-old shortstop prospect Jazz Chisholm, whom the organization views as their future franchise shortstop. Ranked No. 59 overall among MLB prospects and No. 4 within the Marlins' system, Chisholm possesses an elite tool package featuring plus raw power, above-average speed, and gold-glove caliber defense from the shortstop position. MLBPipeline notes he "posts impressive exit velocities from the left side of the plate with an explosive swing that has natural loft" and demonstrated the ability to apply his power across the entire field in 2018 with 25 home runs, the most among minor-league shortstops that season.

Despite his talents, Chisholm has significant development needs. He carries concerning swing-and-miss tendencies, evidenced by a 33.8% strikeout rate in the 2019 season and a .204 average at Double-A at the time of the trade. Over nearly four minor-league seasons as an international free agent signee, he has compiled a .253 career batting average with 53 home runs. Marlins president of baseball operations Michael Hill acknowledged the work ahead but expressed confidence in Chisholm's ceiling, stating he brings "a rare combination of speed and athleticism and power" and that "the sky's the limit" for what he can accomplish. Pipeline projects Chisholm could be ready for his MLB debut as early as 2020.