Scouting Report: Jose Caballero

Summary

José Caballero, 29-year-old Yankees shortstop, has dealt with multiple injuries in May 2026. Initially suffered a right middle finger fracture on May 12 while sliding back into first base against the Brewers, placed on 10-day IL with expected return within 10 days. Subsequently was hit by pitch on left elbow on May 7 and sat out May 9 game but expected to return. Despite injuries, Caballero has shown strong recent performance (.316 BA, .896 OPS over last 22 games with 4 HR and 8 SB) after slow start (.150 BA, .384 OPS in first 12 games). Unseated Anthony Volpe as starting shortstop. Underlying metrics (83.7 mph avg exit velo, 29.3% hard-hit rate, .266 xwOBA) suggest potential regression despite strong surface results.