Generating New Scouting Report
This page will refresh automatically when ready.
Scouting Report
Updated May 19, 2026
Carter Williams is a top prospect shortstop for the Tampa Bay Rays who was recently called up following Jake Fraley's move to the injured list (hernia surgery, 6-8 weeks out). Williams brings a unique profile with three consecutive 20-homer, 20-steal minor league seasons and elite defensive capabilities at shortstop. However, his Triple-A performance shows concerning offensive metrics including a .213 batting average, .318 OBP, .447 SLG, and a strikeout rate exceeding 34%, with particular swing-and-miss issues against secondary pitches. The call-up provides the Rays flexibility in their infield and outfield configurations while reducing reliance on Taylor Walls' limited offensive production.
Strengths
- + Three consecutive 20-homer, 20-steal minor league seasons
- + Top-tier defensive abilities at shortstop
- + Provides infield/outfield flexibility for the Rays
- + Reduces dependency on Taylor Walls' limited offensive output
- + High prospect pedigree and upside
- + Adds athleticism and speed to the lineup
Weaknesses
- - Triple-A batting average of .213 in 2026
- - Strikeout rate exceeding 34% at Triple-A
- - Significant swing-and-miss issues against secondary pitches
- - Weak .318 on-base percentage at Triple-A
- - Limited major league track record
- - May struggle with advanced pitching in MLB
Injury Status: day-to-day
About
Carter Williams is a left fielder for the Milwaukee Brewers.
Player Overview
LF
Milwaukee Brewers